An Anonymous Editor Thinks What The ‘Times’ Did Was Funny
At the end of a mildly amusing story about renovations at Manhattan’s Port Authority Bus Terminal, The New York Times writes this:
“A second person who checked out the women’s restroom — and who asked not to be identified because she has always wanted to be an anonymous source — reported her findings by email: ‘Black shiny granite-y sink. Arched faucets by Sloan. Tasteful slate gray and powder gray tiles.’ “
Is “always wanted to be an anonymous source” a valid reason to grant anonymity? No, Korva. But was it OK this time? Speaking anonymously because he doesn’t want to be drummed out of the Noodge Union, an NPR editor said it felt fine, given the spirit of the story. “Always wanted to be an anonymous source” seems like a parody of the many questionable reasons the Times and other news outlets have granted anonymity in serious stories. There’s a case to be made it worked in this rather cheeky report.
Now, will Times‘ public editor Margaret Sullivan give this line a special place in her “AnonyWatch” series?
For more about NPR’s position on anonymity and related issues, see this post from last August:
“Reminder: Whether To Go With ‘First-Name-Only’ Needs To Be Discussed And Explained”
(H/T Evie Stone.)
(Memmos; Feb. 25, 2015)
February 25, 2015